
San Jose Won Its Opener in Overtime. Is This The Young Sharks' Real Turning Point?
Luca Cagnoni waited nine NHL games for his first goal. When it arrived, it was the overtime winner on opening night. The 21-year-old defenseman scored 3:14 into extra time on Thursday, lifting San Jose to a 4-3 win over the Florida Panthers at SAP Center.
That's about as good a first goal as you can ask for. It also came against a Florida team that won the Stanley Cup in 2024 and 2025.
How a 123rd pick got there
Cagnoni wasn't supposed to be the headline. San Jose drafted him 123rd overall in 2023 after he put up huge numbers for the Portland Winterhawks in the WHL, including a 90-point season that no defenseman in that league had managed in 30 years. He kept improving, earned his first NHL games last season and made the opening-night roster after a strong training camp.
On Thursday, he finished a cross-ice pass from Will Smith, the fourth overall pick in 2023, with a shot that beat Akira Schmid. A 123rd pick finishing a pass from a fourth overall pick is the kind of detail rebuilding teams dream about.
San Jose also added three assists from Macklin Celebrini, the first overall pick in 2024, and two goals from Smith, one short-handed and one on the power play. Newcomer Mason Marchment scored in his Sharks debut. That's a lot of young talent and one veteran signing in a single scoresheet.
The lead that disappeared
The Sharks led 3-0 and then watched it vanish. Eetu Luostarinen scored twice for Florida, and Matthew Tkachuk tied the game 5:18 into the third period, 17 seconds after one of Luostarinen's goals. The Panthers were playing their second game in three nights, having won 1-0 in overtime against Carolina on Tuesday.
Florida also lost captain Aleksander Barkov in the second period after his left knee buckled in a scrum along the boards. Barkov missed all of last season following surgery on his right knee, and his early exit changed the tone of the game for the visitors.
A different kind of rebuild
San Jose finished at the bottom of the NHL standings in 2024-25, and the club has spent the past few years collecting prospects. Celebrini and Smith are the headline pieces. Cagnoni and Sam Dickinson, the 11th overall pick in 2024, are part of the next wave. Goaltender Yaroslav Askarov gave the Hockey News writers plenty to mention after his performance too.
The question is whether the collection has become a team. A roster of talented young players can look great on paper and still struggle with the grind of an 82-game season. Opening night is one data point.
What a turning point actually looks like
Teams rarely identify turning points when they happen. They look back and decide which night mattered. A player who's been in the NHL for ten games scoring a winner against Florida might be the kind of moment that gets remembered, or it might be one good night in October.
The better test comes in February, when the schedule is brutal and the injuries have piled up. A young team that still plays with confidence then has turned something real. One that fades has learned how far it still has to go.
Still, the Sharks should enjoy it. Their prospect pipeline got a vivid moment, their stars scored and assisted, and the visiting team's best player left hurt. It's a good start to a season that began with plenty of doubt.
So is a young team's turning point ever a single game, or does it only exist once everyone looks back?











